Here’s another one from the rejection pile. Submitted this article to Salon.com a couple weeks ago and they didn’t even have to courtesy to e-mail me back to say, “Hey, guy – screw off. You didn’t even mention Obama or the economy once!”
Whatever. As the cashier at Popeye’s told me, I’m too good for them. So here it is, my thin, meandering “Jay Leno is the Richard Nixon of comedy” editorial. Warning: certain themes and ideas below have already made appearances on JG2Land.
P.S. – Yes, it did take the death of Ed McMahon to remind me I wrote this piece. Boo.
JAY LENO: NOW MORE THAN EVER
By James Greene, Jr.
You know what was so epic about Richard Nixon’s resignation from the presidency (aside from the fact it was a resignation from the presidency)? You knew there would never be a comeback. The poor droopy bastard had already done that once, carving out a final legacy on borrowed political time until his own hubris buried it all under six feet of manure. Despite those smirk-inducing “Nixon in ‘88” shirts that popped up a few years later, America knew there was no chance RMN would ever rise from his theoretical grave for another shot at redemption. For a significant chunk of the American people, knowing Nixon couldn’t pull a Freddy Krueger at any given point in time was a huge burden lifted from their weary shoulders.
Yet how would we as a nation have reacted had successor Gerald Ford, in addition to his jaw-dropping pardon, announced in September of ‘74 that Tricky Dick would return shortly to Washington for some kind of useless figurehead position (like, oh, I don’t know, Secretary of Lying About Cambodia)? The stifled rage directed at Ford probably would have boiled over. Perhaps rioters would have burned Yorba Linda to the ground. Perhaps Yale would have tried to revoke Jerry’s law degree. Perhaps Jimmy Carter would have forcibly taken the White House a la Charles Bronson, transforming from meek peanut farmer into the kind of resolute action hero championed a decade later during the Reagan 80s.
The point is, the anger and frustration would have been beyond palpable, just as it was among Gen Y comedy fans late last year when NBC announced that recently departed “Tonight Show” host Jay Leno, the vanilla ice cream/Vanilla Ice of humor, would be returning to the network in September of 2009 for a daily talk exercise at 10 P.M. To the “Ninja Turtles” and Nirvana set, Leno is quite comparable to Tricky Dick: a populist suited figure with a prominent facial protrusion who appeals mostly to Middle America (the Silent Majority). While it’s hard to actively hate or despise Jay Leno, it is easy to dislike him. For seventeen years, he served up lukewarm laughs on “Tonight,” playing it safe and only garnering headlines when he asked Hugh Grant about a blowjob. Leno’s arch rival Letterman may have calmed down significantly by the time Jay pulled ahead of him ratings-wise circa ‘95, but by comparison, Dave had the more exciting, unpredictable show (and most of the time, Letterman was merely quizzing people on cuts of meat and dropping paint from the roof).
As it’s been pointed out so often in recent weeks, “The Tonight Show” brand depreciated in value thanks to Leno. The Dancing Itos and “Jaywalking” were nothing compared to the general tomfoolery of Letterman or previous “Tonight” tenant Johnny Carson. This cheap dollar store edition Leno jockeyed couldn’t go on forever like that. Even Jay himself knew. So, in 2004, it was decided that jittery goofball Conan O’Brien would graduate from his “Late Night” show to the desk once helmed by that white-haired comedy God-among-men. This seemed like the post-Cobain college crowd’s ultimate validation. Corporate America believed in our guy, this rooster-haired lunatic from Harvard who frequently appeared on camera naked, crying, or both. They were gonna beam him from here to Kalamazoo, and if Joe and Jane Lunchpail didn’t like it, they could lump it.
At the time, Leno was quoted as saying we’d see a “smooth transition,” because he didn’t want to relive the ugliness and hurt feelings of his infamous battle to initially gain control of “Tonight” in 1992 (in which his old pal Letterman became his mortal enemy).
“Quite frankly, I don’t want to see anybody go through that again,” said the Mighty Chin.
Well, here we are, into week three or four of “The Tonight Show with Conan O’Brien,” and while the literal transition was smooth and Conan seems to be finding his footing in his new home, there is still a dark, ominous cloud hanging over the proceedings. The vague stress is apparent on the face of all involved. Conan and his crew know they really have to perform in these summer months. They have to build up their brand to Ferrigno-like strengths. If they don’t, come September, they might get steamrolled by the gray-haired smile pusher cruising around his promos in that cherry red sports car. That guy still carries an ample amount of the country’s support. Sure, the official line is “The Jay Leno Show” will provide a strong lead-in to Conan’s program, but the fact of the matter is there’ll be a thirty minute news break between both shows. That’s just enough time to shut off the TV and fall asleep. If Conan can’t charm Middle America harder than the Chin at his absolute ingratiating best, O’Brien might be out of a job by December.
Which is the truly sick thing about “The Jay Leno Show” – it manages to further diminish whatever magic “The Tonight Show” has left by exporting its format to an earlier, safer television time. The whole thrill of that program when Carson hosted it was that it came on after bedtime. You were being granted a special privilege if your folks let you stay up to see even a snippet of it (double so if you made it to Letterman’s bizarre, gimmick-heavy version of “Late Night”). Of course, the idea of dropping mini-Leno into prime time should come as no surprise from the National Broadcasting Company. This is the same network that’s going to take “Weekend Update” from “Saturday Night Live” and inexplicably drop it into Thursday nights. Nothing is more sacred to Jeff Zucker than ratings.
For his part, Conan O’Brien has been quite civil about the entire “Jay Leno Show” affair. He’s thanked Leno on and off the air and only admitted to quietly pondering what Leno’s return will mean in terms of the bigger picture. I’m sure long after O’Brien retires and Leno dies we’ll get the full story, the hard truth that finds Conan confronting his overlords in a curt, angry manner and considering taking a walk like Letterman. Unfortunately, Conan has nowhere else to go. Dave just extended his contract at CBS through 2012. FOX’s late night game has always been poison. ABC’s never been much better (they gave Jimmy Kimmel a show, for the love of Peter Jennings). Too confident to do cable and too wired to hang around waiting to host awards shows, Conan’s gotta stay put until fate intervenes. So Ol’ Red remains cordial, polite, a true gentleman.
Of course, leave it to Norm MacDonald to cut through the bullshit. Appearing on one of O’Brien’s final episodes of “Late Night” last December, the comedian more or less opened with the following remark (eliciting much nervous laughter from Conan):
“It’s stunning how Jay Leno outfoxed you again…everyone thinks like, ‘Oh, I’m Jay Leno,’ they do the voice and everything…meanwhile, he’s the shrewdest guy…you’re in good company – he outfoxed Johnny Carson, he outfoxed David Letterman…every ten years, some red-headed rube shows up…”
This evokes that great Hunter S. Thompson quote about Richard Nixon: “The kind of guy who could shake your hand and stab you in the back at the same time.”
Speaking of Nixon observations, how about the one by Swedish Prime Minister Olof Palme? “He has a technique that I am disconcerted with, because he appeals so forthright, all the time; as soon as he gets entangled, he tries to get sentimental.”
How did Jay Leno choose to end his final “Tonight Show” broadcast, which everyone knew damn well wasn’t any kind of going away party for the genial former Doritos spokesman? By trotting out a bunch of kids, the children of his staffers, and getting sentimental. Leno seemed to be saying, You can’t hate on me. Without my seventeen years of crappy O.J. jokes, these kids wouldn’t exist.
Jay Leno may not have obstructed justice or bombed Cambodia or lied about Vietnam or cursed at a dog named King Timahoe, but the guy certainly is shrewd and tricky. We will have the Chin to kick around again, sooner than you think. The problem with that is the Chin might kick back and inadvertently stomp Conan and “The Tonight Show” into the same void as the missing eighteen minutes from the Watergate tapes. The man has already devalued Carson’s famous franchise. Now, he’s poised to destroy it.